Staff ranks best Girl Scout cookies

It’s Girl Scout cookie season, which means sashes, badges, and boxes of cookies at every street corner. But the eternal debate remains: What is the best Girl Scout cookie flavor? We asked our Hiline staff what their favorite cookie is, and their opinion on the most overated and underated cookies. Take a look at what they had to say.

Kellen Chenoweth

Favorite: Samoas

Most Overated: Thin Mints

Most Underated: Lemonades

 

Myra Stineman

Favorite: Thin Mints

Most Overated: Samoas

Most Underated: Tagalongs

 

Kaitlyn Harris

Favorite: Thin Mints

Most Overated: Samoas

Most Underated: Tagalongs

 

Skylar Promer

Favorite: Somas

Most Overated: Tagalongs

Most Underated: Thin Mints

 

Justine Yang

Favorite: Samoas

Most Overated: Tagalongs

Most Underated: Docedos

 

Ashlyn Keve

Favorite: Tagalongs

Most Overated: Thin Mints

Most Underated: Trefoils

 

Alayna Yates

Favorite: Samoas

Most Overated: Thin Mints

Most Underated: Samoas

 

Chloe Schuerman

Favorite: Samoas

Most Overated: Thin Mints

Most Underated: Samoas

 

Erin McRae

Favorite: Thin Mints

Most Overated: Tagalongs

Most Underated: Samoas

 

Sophia Shillinger

Favorite: Lemonades

Most Overated: Samoas 

Most Underated: Trefoils

 

Quandas Jackson

Favorite: Thin Mints

Most Overated: Tagalongs

Most Underated: Samoas

 

Brian Winkel

Favorite: Lemonades

Most Overated: Thanks-a-Lots

Most Underated: Thin Mints

You must be logged in to post a comment Login

Leave a Reply